Saturday, April 13, 2024

April 2024 ALNB Solo Art Shows - An Appreciation

 The Art League of New Britain has three modest Galleries that are going to host individual Solo Shows.  This is something different and new from recent years.  And its a welcome curatorial innovation.

Photographer Bruce Ferraris, Material Designer and Printmaker Bruce Blackman and Photographer and Watercolorist Ursula Coccomo are the stars of these shows.

As a matter of disclosure, I'm a long time fan/member of the ALNB and both Bruce's are friends and artistic peers who I have a long term familiarity with.  For that reason, the following remarks are an appreciation of the work rather than a criticism.


Bruce Blackman has long been working with the lint fibers that are a byproduct of everyday laundry. Bruce's process is additive and transformative. He creates a visual design that he then overlays with select swatch of lint that he arranges and adheres there. The result is an assemblage whose look and feel will remind the viewer of a Milton Avery painting.

The work is ecclectic and compelling.  Bruce's show includes fine prints and drawings as well.



Ursula Coccomo's show features a variety of romanticized photography whose American lineage can be traced back to Hudson River School roots. These are idyllic scenes from nature that invite patrons and visitors an opportunity to explore and enjoy nature as refined by Ursula's vision.

Her show includes a collection of watercolors - many of the outdoors and some that are simply special interest topics.  All of them nicely crafted and presented.

Ursula's show mutually complements the Stable gallery which is perfect for small and medium sized works and the thematic arc of her work against the rustic wall and floorspace makes for a warm inviting experience.


  
Bruce Ferraris is an enigmatic fellow.  Yes, he's a photographer but his real interest is in a Warholian kind of serialization of "the" image. Instead of repeating an image with the same point of view and allowing for the imperfections of the reproductive process to reveal itself, Bruce floats around that point of view and mixes it up a bit. The result is a drive-by cubist image.  Bruce creates a collective set of these photographs and aesthetically blends a shaken, not stirred final image - kind of like a photographic Margarita.

All of these assemblages are 4 x 4 - some autonomously hung, some are immutably attached to a backing.

Bruce's subject matter in this show is largely to celebrate the taken-for-granted interior stuff of everyday life and make it fresh and interesting.  Pots and pans, junk drawer treasures, and god-knows-what that stuff is is the subject.  Good stuff.

What I love about this new format of one gallery/one artist shows is that, unlike scattershot group shows, an artist can show a range and depth of artistic growth that simply is never otherwise available. 

And shows like this are the finest example of "community" representation.  These are not identity politic advocacies.  Nobody is mirroring skin color, sexual preference, or any other such private triggering mechanism.  These are also artists who volunteer routinely to keep these places healthy, vibrant, and open to *EVERYBODY* both as participants and viewers.

There is no excuse to claim you don't have the opportunity to see, meet, and break bread with great artists if  you don't show up.

GO and enjoy.


Thursday, April 11, 2024

Tip-Toeing Through CT Arts Grants

 In researching *how to* apply for government arts grants (my art career plan B), I started with local grants and that exercise exploded in my face and escalated to Regional and Federal levels of interest. It is unavoidable. And it's circular.  I'm back to the CT State mosh pit of Arts funding.

As a software engineer there's a conceptual framework that ought to apply to the awarding of Fellowship grants or institutional funding is "As above, so below". For sports enthusiasts this translates to "The goalposts shouldn't be moving." In CT anything can happen.  Let's dive in.

The CT Artist Fellowship Program 2023 Recipient List is here. The accuracy of the information appears to be approximate on closer inspection. My interest as a visual artist was to attempt to identify some kind of pattern of award and what I found was a rich, superficial diversity of identity politic types. Any discrimination in that regard appears co-incidental - I poked through a number of years. I had no real ability to speak to viewpoint diversity.

What I did find are a few backdoor things that imply that the rules for Fellowship qualification are not rigorously enforced.  One problem was actual residency (being a New England artist isn't someone necessarily paying CT State taxes) and the second problem is the greased pig identity problem of whether or not such a person really exists.  Later.

Of the 69 Fellowships awarded, I teased out that 31 of the 69 artists listed had something to do with the Visual Arts - my particular special interest. So I really took a close look at those and sampled a few others to confirm the problem I found.

And that problem involves the fact that 15 of the 31 Fellowships went to instructors or employees in Higher Education institutions. Six of those 15 are associated with Yale and 9 in other higher ed schools.

I think a similar ratio of Fellowship particulars will play out with the rest of the non-Visual artists listed.

As feedback that could and should alert the DECD that the system is broken. If a quarter or more of the Fellowships being awarded are going to the graduates of the world's richest University and another quarter to graduates of exclusive institutions, then Federal and State money intended to promote equity is in fact being money laundered back into the pockets of the rich.

What my research has helped me to do is conclusively define who the "underserved" CT artists actually are.  The underserved community consists of anyone who did not graduate with an MFA from Yale or other exclusive institution.  This is worth unpacking.  It is not patriarchy, racism, systemic government breakdown or any other popular victim narrative that suppresses a livelier arts culture in CT (and maybe New England), it is social class education.

The total amount of money at the end of the spigot for actual artists struggling to create a maker budget is half of that more or less $200K yearly payout. ALL the rest of the arts funding is administrative overhead - we're talking about hundreds of millions of dollars.

But we can't be done yet,  What about institutional funding?

"The pandemic and COVID-related restrictions have hit these organizations hard. Theaters and other performing arts venues were recently given the go-ahead to open to the public as part of the state’s Phase 3 reopening plan but only at 50% capacity, further undermining their ability to turn a decent profit.

In a news release, Connecticut’s Flagship Producing Theaters, a consortium of theaters that includes Eugene O’Neill Theater Center, Goodspeed Musicals, Hartford Stage, Long Wharf Theatre, Westport Country Playhouse and Yale Repertory Theatre called the grant program “a welcome step toward helping theaters recover.”"

So what the hell is the Yale Repertory Theater doing in this mix? Make this make sense. Was there ever some doubt that F'n YALE was in danger of going under?  And the State put some qualifications on this funding that YALE, of all places, would have absolutely no problem maxing out should they so choose.

Google:

And about 5% of that is spent funding Yale:

So what condition is Yale Rep in these days?

"“I think her legacy is already operating out there in the field,” said James Bundy, who as dean of the Yale School of Drama and artistic director of Yale Rep has worked alongside of Nolan for 17 years. “It’s in all the leaders that she’s had such an important role in training.” Nolan, who announced her decision back in October and is succeeded by Florie Seery, has seen the theatrical landscape evolve first-hand from her multifaceted position at Yale. As a shrewd managing director and innovative educator, Nolan is as responsible as any one person for how theaters operate across the commercial and nonprofit spectrum countrywide.

Naturally, her influence started in New Haven.

“We were a $16 million operation then,” said Nolan of Yale Rep’s operating budget, “and $40 million now."

DECD funds Yale Rep approx. $43325 per year (2018 - today, likely long before 2018 as well). These Directed Local Funds got even funkier in 2022 and 2023 when some kind of 2 year state carry forward windfalls were added $129,975 and $86,000 were added to the funding. SWEET. Go Yale.

Compare and contrast.


Friends of mine compare applying for arts funding as a crab bucket exercise.    There's no such intention here.  This process is highly flawed and needs fixing. I hope these essays clarify some solutions.

My first recommendation is that if funding is going to involve residency then that residency have a threshold of three continuous years in the State. Residency less than that limits the grant to its lowest possible award.  This rewards long term resident artists and limits academic drive-bys.

Second, add aliases. The gaming of identity masks the number of applications, awards, and residences that craftier agents use to obfuscate their history.

Encrypt all personal characteristics of the applicant. Let the quality of the art speak to the virtue of the application and the individuals involved.  Nobody wants their awarded funding to be diminished by the innuendo that they "didn't earn it" (DEI).


 




Tuesday, April 9, 2024

Federal Art Funding Done Right

 In the 1960's Major League Baseball expanded and added back another New York team, the New York Mets.  Needless to say as an expansion team the talent was razor thin and their colorful and entertaining coach Casey Stengel quipped, "Doesn't anybody here know how to play this game?"

That sense of humor is not lost on any artist attempting to locate and apply for a arts grant or other funding opportunity from the State of CT, the New England Foundation for the Arts (NEFA), and to some degree the National Endowment for the Arts (NEA).

Aside from the clusterMuck of confusing and misleading website and - cough- "portal" interface problems, it is a full time chore for anyone who is not already associated with a mainstream arts organization, a University, or otherwise inside track to simply navigate, recipe-wise, 'how do I apply for the damned thing and how can I be sure my application will be treated fairly'?

I'm chipping away at making sense of this stuff in a series of essays and inquiries that I hope will concise road map that any artist can follow.

What has caught my attention and has answered the question of "Can the Federal government do a good and truly honest job of creating opportunities for creatives whose instructions are reasonable, whose solicitations are free of cognitive and political bias, and who advocate and practice an even handed evaluation process?"

The improbable answer is YES.

In researching arts funding you will inevitably encounter cross references to the National Endowment for the Humanities. Sometimes that cross-reference is misguided.  In a couple of cases, an arts administrator or political advocate for funding wants to co-opt or deflect responsibility for funding something having to do with writing or related matter for funding as a Humanities project. NEA and NEH serve two autonomous and unique cohorts that only co-incidentally share some of the same creative juices that applicants are looking to exercise.

On the NEH website there's a webinar that's been recorded with tons of very useful, specifics about who the Humanities serve and what the scope of that stuff is as this slide shows;



Taken at face value, artists such as myself can claim some of that territory as our own but what NEH makes clear throughout their material is that the generation of art is out of scope - that stuff belonging to the responsibility of the NEA, NGOs, and private parties


Again, as an artist, I find comfort in this kind of clarity. This means that funding opportunities for stuff I do or hope to do is in the scope of the NEA and not here.  HOWEVER, my expectation as an artist is that everything that applies to the Humanities in terms of an expected field of neutrality WILL apply at the NEA.

Let's compare and contrast what i found in the NEA budget and performance plan:


Wait, WHAT?

I'm going to analyze the NEA's malfeasance in this regard in a separate essay. Obviously, every single form of psychological intimidation appears to be "the plan" at the NEA.

But this post is about doing it right and for the sake providing how its done right let me provide additional references and links from NEH that conclusively prove that government can work responsibly and fiscally soundly.

The NEH grants webpage is a breath of fresh air - lots of truly well-developed recipes for successfully submitting an application for the funding you hope will be chosen.

The YouTube channel for NEHgov is rich with additional videos that make life easier for funding applicants.

see: Connecticut Humanities Grants

















Thursday, April 4, 2024

Art as Intelligent Alien Being

 I have been interested and studying the use of the word 'language' in art criticism and conversation for quite a while now. There's something condescending about someone using it out of the blue when you're looking at a piece of art.

Why don't I see that?  Am I stupid?  WTF are they talking about?  Language? Is this just bullshit warmed over?

I took a communications course decades ago. Sender and receiver are two necessary components for communication to take place.  Language is tightly coupled to this. Whatever a sender is sending needs to be decoded into meaningful substance and acknowledged (received). Implicit in this exchange is the mutual coding of information into a transmissible language or set of reusable, recognizable notation.

When I'm observing an art object, I rarely sense that an artist is transmitting a message in a language unless its already just using an existing written code.  This doesn't mean that art objects can't emote sympathy or triggered emotion based on the composition and aesthetic material used to generate those responses. To me that's a call/response reactionary impulse.

And, I'm not the first to comment on the subject.  My own interest was intrigued by James Elkins book Why Art Cannot Be Taught. In a section on Critiques, he refers to a concept called theory speak - that of a vernacular tightly coupled to a material, theoretical, or otherwise esoteric aspect of aesthetic practice that acts as a common ground for discussing the subject (the art, the practice, the artist's trajectory, and so on).

In another example he talks about critiquing a painting by a student who claims that the painting contains a language. After asking the student how Elkins might say something in the language, the student more accurately explains the painting as a personal narrative describing a camping trip.

For a long time that was my hangup.  The use of the concept of language that referred to someone's art was something I automatically assumed was an attempt at one-up-manship regarding a recognizable pattern, style, or esoteric component of any given artist's canon.

And I have studied Wittgenstein's work implying we can't/shouldn't talk about art - a notion that has a romantic appeal but also leaves us with the unintentional consequence of being mutual aesthetically mute and dumb orphans. We can and do talk about art - tfb.

With all of that as intellectual baggage, I am reading Thierry de Duve's Pictoral Nominalism (On Duchamp's Passage from Painting to the Readymade). TdD is one of the most insightful Duchamp historians but its never an easy read - he demands a lot of attention and the subject matter is dense and deep. I'll not attempt a literary swim in the deeper waters.

There's a short bit about Kandinsky that I want to appropriate as a complement to a theory I want to propose.


Nominalism is a philosophical construct that asserts that the abstract doesn't exist - that every single entity is it's autonomous self (I'm generalizing but stick with me for the ride).

Alright, buckle your seat belt. If the abstract doesn't exist - let's buy the argument - then what the hell are these "...self-sufficient, spiritually breathing subject that also leads a material life: it is a being"

Let's play with that idea. TdD's book follows Duchamp's investigation and re-theorization of language itself. Both a decomposition of how reality is cognitively managed and objectively how it comes to *be*. Here, Kandinsky - maybe because of spirituality blinders that he shared with Hilma af Klint - misses the opportunity to solve a universal question. Is the work of art that "rises from out of the artist" an object or an alien being - the very intelligent life humankind has searched for from the days of primal soup?

Art objects defy everything we associate with searches for intelligent life yet if we squint our preconceived notions just a bit and apply a nominal lens to our focus, maybe we are sharing our planet with galactic stuff we don't yet recognize or acknowledge.

As for artistic language, TdD extends our (my) original presumptions about language with these thoughts.


Ah, "a fiction of a language".  That's really interesting given how loosely so many art critics use the concept.  In reading this book, language doesn't come cheap to artists and never arrives for most. I was warned by Richard Trickey at UNL not to allow myself the mistake of assuming that discussing art was just bullshit, it's not.  

But buyer beware when critics claim an intellectual fast lane into the language of a given artist.

You've taken the ride this far.  Here's a TED talk that complements the idea that art objects in a nominal world may in fact represent a form of alien life as aesthetic memes.  







 



NEA First Inquiry -NEFA Concerns

 NEFA Concerns

Fromkrasicki@protonmail.com <krasicki@protonmail.com>

Topublicaffairs@arts.gov, oig@arts.gov

CCkrasicki@protonmail.com

DateThursday, April 4th, 2024 at 12:17 PM

Yesterday I called the NEA and spoke with someone who advised that I send an email to document my concerns.

I am semi-retired at the moment, a lifelong artist, I've dedicated quite a bit of time to unpacking and disentangling American Arts funding nationally and at local levels. I consider this the first of what I expect to be more correspondences as the feedback cycle will generate additional questions and areas of research.

Today I want to address two specific areas of inquiry and concern. One is the governance of NEA's regional affiliates. In my case, the New England Foundation for the Arts.

My understanding from yesterday's phone call is that 40% of all NEA arts funding is distributed to these regional affiliates. If I assume that to be true, then as an artist I can apply directly to the NEA for Federal grant money which is sourced from 60% of the total NEA budget allocated for that purpose and that I can apply to my regional Arts affiliate for grants sourced from some percentage of the 40% of the budget made available to a specific region. Importantly, in order to apply for such grants or opportunities,

I must somehow both navigate to and through the application process AND be provided some set of understandable instructions for successfully doing so.

AND, implicitly, anyArtist should not be coerced into political loyalty oaths, political identity litmus tests, illegal constraints on the creation or content of my proposal, or other illegitimate expectations. Equally, implicit, is the clear and unambiguous understanding that the art being proposed or advocated for consideration will be evaluated strictly on its own merit and accepted or not based on those metrics. Presumably, American citizens over the age of 18 is the only qualification and that the solicitation for grants or whatever is for art​.

Please do correct my understanding of how the NEA funding operates is any of this is wrong or sadly mistaken (and I'm not naive enough to believe that, in practice, there's a broader range of interpretation by certain individuals administering the programs).

Assuming that as a context that anyArtist can expect and given that the only​access to NEFA arts funding is through NEFA's web portal, anyArtist has absolutely no other alternative for application for funding, grants, and so on.

However there are differences between the NEA's broad spectrum of art opportunities and NEFA's regional subset. I documented those differences in on my art criticism blog; https://artscrub.blogspot.com/2023/08/the-criminal-negligence-of-new-england.html

Nothing has changed. In essence, the NEA - instead of ensuring a consistent funding distribution model based on professional practice, say Visual Arts - distributes funding opportunities by geography and geography is implemented on that local level by funding power brokers who can constrain (or more accurately operate a money laundering operation) because they abuse the system to empower themselves to. The corruption of opportunity is contagious to even finer grains of more local funding on the State level (a different discussion). Numerous categories of professional art activity are missing.

And this speaks directly to my first empirical complaint - the NEFA site is a, for lack of a better term, woke hellhole of political advocacy, racial and identity politic litmus tests and more. There is nothing balanced and there is no avenue for a professional anyArtist to navigate a neutral, unbiased, nonconformist application process. Conservative or disinterested artists are wholly discouraged to apply or even think that their applications - barring a word salad of magic associations - will ever be taken seriously. This is a big problem.

The problem gets even bigger when anyArtist examines the NEFA Terms of Use for the (reminder) only portal to apply for the 40ish% of regional funding. The TOU is self-referential as a legally binding agreement yet contains numerous passages that are entirely capitalized. In digital form, the convention of using all caps is to be screaming - needless to say, not a typical legally formulated convention to my knowledge.

More to the point, the TOU is unusual in that it attempts to insulate NEFA from all and any accountability for their implementation and administration of federal (and State) arts funding. Many of its assertions appear to be, at face value, entirely an attempt to subvert the legal rights of artists to engage in legal remedy. Only one other region, the South copies the TOU (badly - misspellings and maybe other quirks).

Section 12d, essentially eliminates your ability to access the funding opportunities:

" BY ACCEPTING THESE TCU, YOU WAIVE AND HOLD HARMLESS NEFA FROM ANY CLAIMS RESULTING FROM ANY ACTION TAKEN BY NEFA DURING OR AS A RESULT OF NEFA’S INVESTIGATION AND/OR FROM ANY ACTIONS TAKEN AS A CONSEQUENCE OF INVESTIGATIONS BY EITHER NEFA OR LAW ENFORCEMENT RELATED TO YOUR USE OF THE SERVICES. IF YOU BELIEVE THAT CONTENT REMAINS ON THE SERVICES WHICH VIOLATES YOUR RIGHTS OR THESE TCU, AS STATED IN SECTION 15, YOUR SOLE AND EXCLUSIVE REMEDY AGAINST NEFA SHALL BE TO TERMINATE YOUR USE OF THE SERVICES."

I don't know why no one reads or realizes that this amounts to intimidation and the normalization of the abuse of the legal system by this arts organization.

OTOH, other regions (see MidAtlantic Region) acknowledge the legal rights and remedies available to artists in their TOU for geographical domain portals.I will publish this as an open correspondence on my blog artscrub.blogspot.com and update it with your feedback. My long term intent is to create a HOWTO set of instructions for anyArtist to follow to apply for funding opportunities so this is a work in progress, one small step at a time.

regards,

Frank Krasicki

Sent with Proton Mail secure email.

Monday, March 25, 2024

2024 CT+6: Guerrilla Girl Body Count

 Jurors: Eric Aho, artist and Brian Galloway, Owner/Director of the William Scott Gallery, Provincetown, MA


Work by 76 Women and 33 Men accepted

Friday, March 15, 2024

Essay: Art and Social Risk

 There's an increasingly troubling political weaponization of art shows. Numerous mainstream art media channels increasingly normalize taking advantage of the art ecosystem as an exclusive and private political echo chamber and sandbox for an intolerant cohort of "collaborators".

The opportunity for true terrorism to be staged in the subterfuge of a Contemporary Art show is growing and may be breaching a dangerous critical mass.

The concern falls into a number of categories;

  • The use of art shows by political cohorts to communicate, co-ordinate, or orchestrate illegal or terrorist activity 

  • The use of art shows by political cohorts to smuggle or otherwise exchange weaponry or other materials to disrupt social stability 

  • The use of art shows as a means to trigger or otherwise alter the behavior of a patron that results in a spontaneous reckless act of aggression or trauma

 The show and artist who inspired these observations is Tania El Koury who talked about her work in a Brooklyn Rail "New Social Environment" zoom call event.  

There is nothing about Koury's art to indicate anything but sincere aesthetic considerations but the implementation of her installations is worth examining in the context of this essay. 




This piece, Cultural Exchange Rate, is of particular interest.  It consists of locked Cabinet spaces that are opened by patrons with a key that's distributed by whoever is responsible for sitting the show on any given day. Khoury's work deconstructs some personally archival material that is distributed piecemeal among these cabinets. 

The patrons pictured have a relatively autonomous and personal experience but, obviously, there is no transparency as to the contents of any of these containers.

Given the global aspects of shows such as these shows - international special interest groups promoting their own agendas - the potential for ethnic and geopolitical intrigue is certainly a consideration worth discussing. In a violent world, Contemporary Art shows that feature coded political agendas or provide hidden opportunities for the exchange of contraband, or can co-ordinate private, exclusive access to designated spaces is problematic.  The list of abusive examples is much longer than my shortlisted items.

The artistic ecosystem needs to re-calibrate its attention to artistic concerns and reject the normalization of art as politics as religion in a world so polarized as to promote mutual distrust and harm. 



 

Sunday, March 10, 2024

The Avant-Grind - Making Sense of Juried Art Shows in the 21st Century

It is a long standing convention for Juried Art shows to solicit a call for artists to submit their entries to the show based on work realized in the past, say, three years. The temporal requirement will vary and may be based only years or social event such as the Covid social isolation period. 

I bring up this topic because of the assumptions that never are questioned about the practice.

In a society in which individuals are living longer and more capable lives, artists who are older often have a large inventory of material to choose from with the last n number of years representing but a small fraction of their intellectual contributions, curiosities, and development.

Last century which was dominated by the romantic notion of the "avant-garde" - the notion that each professional artist is willingly or unwillingly enrolled in a race that represented progress as establishing a unique stream of theory or practice both different and theoretically plausible than the next artist. Furthermore, the act of being a professional artist was neither as crowded an occupation as it is today nor as fiscally viable. Compound all of that with uncertain health and lifetime expectations and often artists of that time became hostages to the choice of aesthetic rabbit hole "ism" they decided to pursue and call their own.

And as a consequence, galleries, curators, dealers, and patrons became accustomed to uniformly demanding the latest, greatest progress along these lines.  The "new", the "cool", the avantiness of the work is what everyone was tapping their foot waiting to be delivered.

By the end of the last century though the avant-garde had largely run its course, intellectually burying with the widely hailed "Death of..."  all things Modern. And today with the smoking fumes of PostModernism still fresh in the air, galleries still cling to and promote juried shows whose metrics and expectations are artifacts of a culturally unfamiliar past.

Unlike museums, galleries that solicit calls for art are precisely where local communities can find and freely access the diverse cacophony of artistic talent our political identitarians claim to look for.  

Contemporary Art is a big tent that straddles fine art and everything else that somebody/anybody considers "art" and heaven forbid you question any of its worthiness.

The pretension of an avant-garde in the 21st century simply has lost its veracity. Art is less a matter of developing an "ism" as it is a cult like devotion to believing one's identity cohort is in need of a space so safe as to deny any and all forms of discussion or criticism as unwelcome or even an assault on their personage.

And this brings us back - in a roundabout way - to questioning the virtue of requesting that artistic submissions to juried art shows conform to a newness metric - something completed in the last n years.

Today, the result is not a harvest of originality or innovation.  The result is both politically correct and politically policed conformity. The galleries are aesthetic echo chambers of empty virtue and antiseptic craft competitions.  The temporal constraints on these shows artificially create a bubble of illiberal conformity.

If an avant garde exists today, it is practiced not with ideas but in aesthetic delivery systems - digital, virtual, and augmented technologies abound.  What is persistently a vacant opportunity is the ability to present new ideas, thoughtful  contradictory musings, or -gasp- original material that has no Contemporary comfort zone.

Let's spitball some alternative curatorial possibilities.  How about juried shows that ask for a current piece and a piece from ten years ago to compare and contrast. Or why pursue temporal bounds on show entries at all?   Long practicing artists have plenty of unseen and underappreciated work worth presenting.



Friday, February 16, 2024

Bigotry at the Brooklyn Rail

 The Brooklyn Rail (BR) is a multimedia, Brooklyn based, arts social media outlet.  They publish a newsletter and provide a Monday thru Friday zoom to YouTube artist or arts organization interview that presumably anyone can participate in. Usually this involves one hundred or fewer live participants and a few dozen additional YouTube views. 

The Zoom meetings include the ability to hold a side chat between one another audience members. The principals in the Zoom conversation can choose to see or ignore these comments and these comments never show up in the YouTube exports of the Zoom call.

And these chat room conversations are moderated - presumably to eliminate any inappropriate remarks or malicious content in the chat room. One would hope that the moderation isn't intended to exercise bigotry against legitimate material being shared.

Unfortunately, the Brooklyn Rail podcasts are moderated in a way that calling it The Brooklyn Bus of Bigotry would be a more appropriate label for the enterprise.

The BR's subtitle claims "Critical Perspectives on Arts, Politics and Culture" but doesn't really practice it. With few exceptions the editorial hegemony that governs all of its content is closer to an exercise in liberal fascism than Critical Perspective. The explicit allegation about their representation is that they represent and defend the intellectual voices of the marginalized, under-represented, and, well, the litany of victimization adjectives is far too long to list. Suffice it to say that no identity politic group is too small or ridiculous to be included in this community.

A practicing artist, minding their own business, and attempting to make apolitical art is not welcome in that cohort. 'Community' by their practical definition doesn't include anyone who isn't a victim (e.g. you or I). And therein lies not only the root of the bigotry but the weaponization of amplifying race, gender, skin color, sexual preference, and so on as a profit platform.

The editorial architecture of the BR guarantees a strict and unapologetic conformity of thought and opinion. The BR employs a number of editors whose specialty is the bigotry of low expectations. Their gender editors are gay, queer, or non-binary and their guests always identify by gender. Rare if ever is there a discussion about art that isn't a fawning, mutual gender admiration discussion. Art is always the collateral neglected topic.

Likewise with the Trump Derangement Syndrome editors. In these interviews the artist being featured must spend at least fifteen minutes showing their politically correct inoculation credentials. They hate Trump, love BLM, are not sexually straight, their personal identity is a mystery to everyone, they've been marginalized by the mythic patriarchy, they decolonize their lives with anti-Western bleach, and on and on and on.  No evidence is ever required and no logical coherency is ever offered.
dare to ask what any of it has to do with their art in the chat and you will be eliminated from addressing the chat group with all comments going to the null bin direct messages of the moderator of the day.

"The New Social Environment is a space for community and intellectual exchange. Please be generous with each other, and allow us all space to interpret and discuss."

Some BR editors constrain conversations to art and they are often richer and more generally worthwhile participatory fare.

As a platform, one of many problems is the fact that all of their Zoom moderators are young and female. Aside from Phong Bui, the publisher, there is not a male speaker to be found among the general staff.

The women find every Zoom participant "awesome", "generous", and "amazing".  And the experience of the Zoom calls is often that of an echo chamber with designated chat cheerleaders who elevate even the most mundane artistic exchanges as epiphanies. To offer any contradictory input is troublesome.

And therein lies the biggest problem the BR promotes.  that is that the so-called "New Social Environment" is not only no better than the old one but an insultingly condescending alternative.

If artists "of color" are looking for equality, one would think that treating them with equal respect would mean having adult conversations about their art and process.  Likewise, young women who claim an entitlement to privileged representation in galleries, museums, and shows need to provide some/any evidence that their art deserves such favor. They don't. In the New Social Environment they can freely vent their spleen full of alleged evils by men without a hint of proof.

Other groups all enjoy this non-critical pretense of victimization and birthright innocence while condemning the other - whoever they think they are.

All of this is to say that this echo chamber mentality ensures new generations of racism, victim-hood, and  needy narcissism that does nothing more than pollute a generous society that does its imperfect best to create a better world. And a better world lifts every aesthetic ship.


    

Wednesday, January 3, 2024

Guerrilla Girls 2023 EOY Cumulative Body Count

 In 2023, in 17 juried or otherwise selected visual art gallery shows in the Northeast;


576 women were chosen to exhibit (65%)

309 men were chosen to exhibit (35%)

2 self-identified Trans were chosen (.2%) 

 

Two Foundations Pollock/Krasner & Joan Mitchell) awarded

55 women and 39 men grants


Collector spending via ArtBasel study: 

2.6 HNW collectors spent less on works by female artists in 2022 and 2023, with a ratio by value of 39% female to 61% male

In other words, galleries are losing money thanks to their imbalances.

Motivations of collectors.

In other words, galleries that don't account for who their patrons are miss the commercial opportunities.


The National Endowment for the Arts reports that 46.1% of visual artists are women.    Few highly reliable, least biased resources exist.

THE NEA report has LOTS of good, interesting, and actionable data that should temper the rhetoric concerning under-representation, "erasure", and other volumes of unsubstantiated discrimination claims.


Two shows include in this count had no previous mention and were researched by their conspicuous absence.


The 2023 Silvermine 'One' juried show:
 
27 women, 3 men accepted


The Hudson Juried Artist show:

 70 women and 60 men accepted




Sunday, December 17, 2023

Women Reframe American Landscape - NBMAA, Part 3

So what is the point of this show again?

The pretense of this show - the excuse for yet another Guerrilla Girl sorority occupation of a major American Art museum - is that 19th century women landscape painters are somehow under-exposed under the curatorial framework of Hudson River School artists.  Untangling the poor documentation of the Hudson River School legacy requires also wearing wading boots through the further GG's swamp of obfuscation and convoluted misdirection.  

Who are the Hudson River School?

First understand school as if it were a school of fish.  It is a fluid and highly diluted term for an increasingly growing subset of all American landscape painters regardless of identity politic persuasion. However, money and subliminal political blackmail talk loudly and my earlier comments in Part One and in Part Two speak to my opinions and concerns.

Curatorially and traditionally, prestigious museums attempt to represent the finest examples of the subject(s) they may be exhibiting, researching, or promoting the discovery of. In more recent years, the assault on these institutions has crippled the ability of these institutions to ethically and professionally function.

So it is up to critics such as myself to research and educate patrons of the arts as to the veracity of shows such as these that smell of dubious quality.

Let's narrow candidates who belong on the short list of artists who can be recognizably identified as members of the Hudson River School (HRS) of artists as those listed in Wikipedia's short list. Susie M. Barstow, among other females (not that this show has anything to do with sex!). So that's not a bone of contention.

Something that is argued by the curators of this show however is that Barstow has been historically abused. This drips with irony as Barstow's work constitutes abut half of the third of the show dedicated to 19th century women artists who made art during that period. The aesthetic floggings continue - poor Susie.

So, What's the Geographic and Temporal Context for this Part of the Show?

More precisely, the historically bounded Hudson River School's important activity happens between 1825 and fading by 1875 - a fifty year run though many of the artists lived and worked longer to diminishing or changing interest.

The artists in question begin working not much sooner than 50 years after the Revolutionary War and the War of 1812 is still a fresh memory. 

In 1825 there are 24 states in the Union.  In 1875, ten years after the Civil War, there are 37 states in the Union and by 1890 there are 44.

The effects of the Industrial Revolution arrive in America from 1830 to 1840. This includes the proliferation of tourist steamboats out of NY City up the Hudson River. The Catskills become early vacation and tourist destinations for the wealthy. In 1837, the Adirondacks are mapped and by the 1870's routine access to the Adirondacks broadens the geographic scope of these artists.

The temporal sweet spot for the production of HRS artwork by its most famous practitioners is 1830 - 1860.  There's nothing absolute about this as there is an original cohort of artists followed by a second-generation whose work is closely coupled to the HRS profile and prescription. The National Academy of Design becomes a proxy for the HRS artists during this time.

Portable metallic tubes for oil paint are invented in 1841.

Thomas Cole who starts the historically significant HRS landscape painting movement dies in 1848.  

Barstow would have been 12 years old at that time. By 1860, Barstow is 24 and so she is clearly a second generation artist in this category and any claim that she is being marginalized really needs to explain away how she could be confused with the first generation of artists who defined the genre. 

Nine years after Cole's death, in 1857, the 10th Street Studio is opened In New York City. This is where both male and female, famous and wannabe HRS artists establish studios. Cole spent most of his career living and working in Cedar Grove in the Catskills.

A publication called The Crayon is published between 1855 - 1861 and essays in it prescribe very specific instructions for the creation of HRS paintings. By now, innovation within HRS practice is discouraged and rejected.

It should also be noted that landscape painting is unrivaled during these few decades. Google has created a very good timeline of the scope of work.

The NBMAA HRS Collection

 Gallery 5 on the first floor of the museum holds a rich and varied collection of HRS works and it should be made much more obvious that these works complement the WRAL show upstairs.  For grins and giggles let's see what the museum has to say about them.


IMO, this is pretty thin gruel.  It reads like the summary paragraphs of a high school essay assignment.

And its very little help in attempting to ground any of the women artists upstairs. A more detailed timeline and nuanced explanation of likenesses and differences in style would be far more useful considering the richness of the collection.

Where Susie Barstow Fits

The body of work that we get exposed to in the Suzie Barstow section of the show is a sparse sampling.  The majority of pieces do not stand out even as HRS candidate pieces. They are plain, sometimes dull, and not particularly interesting nature snapshots.

The pieces that do distinguish themselves, distinguish themselves in aesthetic sweetness.  Barlow, unlike many of the other artists involved, seems to have developed a color scheme that amplifies the landscape colors.  Rather than sublime the landscape colors pop in both impossible and irresistible ways. Barstow's best work is well-crafted, commercial quality illustration.
 
And, based on the samples exhibited the paintings emulate the HRS look, they never achieve the spirituality that Cole, Church, or others succeeded in projecting.  Nor are her pieces particularly atmospheric (see: Inness or Bridges work in the galleries).  In fact, for Barstow and many of her circle the compositions and problem space are boilerplate, compositionally centered and predictable outdoor scenes.

The scenes consist of a stream or pool of water surrounded by banks of  paper birch trees. Light effects are redundant from one painting to another.  Whatever abstraction exists within the paintings appear to be the byproduct of efficiency and economy rather than experiment or improvisation. 

The larger issue is that much of the pedestrian HRS look and feel is being produced at the end of the century seems to be homogenized. This may speak to the demands of the remaining patrons who had not yet abandoned the genre or it may simply speak to a long tail commercialization that in scarcity required ever sweeter and domestic cosmetic changes.

And the rhetorical descriptions that bookend her work as well as the others is that they were outdoors doing all the same stuff the male artists were doing.  That's true. But is it exceptional for women at the time and the answer is no. In fact one of the accusations about the HRS painters is that their work became a tourist magnet to the area that eventually despoiled the landscape.

In other words, *everybody* who could afford it vacationed or traveled up the Hudson, into the woods, and, because photography was a new and not ubiquitously available, people either sketched or bought prints of the places they visited - a perfect storm for the commercial success of the HRS cohort.

Barstow simply conducted a train the trainer business - teaching teachers the HRS principles and selling the resulting craftwork.

Unpacking the Rise and Fall of the HRS

Thomas Cole and those he influenced most greatly were romanticists first and foremost with a heavy dose of, let's call it Dark Nouveau - darker mythological themes found in the more decorative Art Nouveau genre.

His paintings would include American Indians who were no longer occupying the territory, fairies, Biblical allusions, and dystopian visions of nature trampled by the march of progress. While the GGs argue that there is no Eden and Eden never existed, they disparage the evidence of Cole's art.

Cole and others shared a sacred vision of nature - a religiously colored gaze. Cole is not painting actual representation - not plein air. Sketching Clubs (male, female, and coed) existed because sketching was the more effective and efficient way to capture scenic information.  And these paintings were taken as the best knowledge available for urban populations to actually see and dream the New World.

Cole's paintings are exercises in transcribing his sketches through his religious memory gaze of the, now, composite landscape scene. There is little botanical accuracy involved in his work and he will be criticized for these very reasons much as he is aesthetically valorized for the same reasons. 

In this context, Barstow and her generation of landscape painters explore the same intellectual territory as Cole's cohort with the added advantage that the geography is well documented, the ability to paint plein air is much easier due to tube paints, and the formula for the HRS landscapes is already baked.

For patrons then and now, the accuracy of Barstow's botanical studies, her craft of picture-making, and her understanding of the formula are as good, better, and good enough to admire and love regardless of their historical or intellectual ranking.

The Fall

There's an unfortunate generalization about the demise of the HRS genre and that is that a criticism of the work appearing in a New York newspaper unexpectedly and conclusively diminished the value and prestige associated with the work of these artists.  More truthfully, the piece was a broadside by Impressionist challengers to the status quo.

A second, far more important, complementary barometer of change, can also be found in the NBMAA collections and that is the art of Marie Cassatt whose conversion to Impressionism is compelling and disruptive. The artistic changes in her art signal as well as anyone's the advent and ubiquitous conquest of the French Impressionists and multiple waves of Modern Art that will submerge and swamp any market for previous generations of American art - HRS being no exception.

The stagnation and relatively old-fashioned landscape narrative gives way to figuration at home and aesthetic revolution abroad.  The women exhibited in this show remained forever anchored to this fashion. The as now, American educators are the last to learn or change.

The Pyramid Scheme

HRS paintings are rebounding in value by leaps and bounds.  As with so many mediocre women artists who are disingenuously being promoted as individuals far more significant than they really were or are - buyer beware.  The wake of GG advocacy seems to be a pump and dump aesthetic behavior that really needs some examination.  Museums who should and in many cases do know better are selling off masterworks to acquire work out of the car trunks of less than credible dealers who manufacture and depend on identity politics to leverage their wares.

Barstow has been compared to Jervis McEntee. The art of the two is distinctly different. What is worth noting and comparing is the fact that McEntee is a lesser known HRS artists and that he, like Barstow, continued painting well after the HRS declines in popularity.

His journals deserve research funding more than another GG episode of Mr. Peabody and Sherman rewrite American Art History.